Member |
Question [To Administrators] |
|
James R. Davis
Administrator
17375 Posts
[Mentor]
Houston, TX
USA
Honda
GoldWing 1500
|
Posted - 01/27/2009 : 1:01 PM
Like
|
Associated Topic wasquote: At first glance, I liked the sound of a venue like Ask Our Mentors where members can pose critical questions and mentors can respond. However, now I wonder whether the group of mentors might now become somewhat "sticky", and fixed - at most - to its current membership.
This isn't a criticism so much as a curiosity. That said, I'm making the following assumptions: - Most posts that get a peer review are for specific responses to questions as opposed to simple back-and-forth banter.
- Individuals who want specific answers to a question will now tend to only use the Ask Our Mentors forum.
If these assumptions are true (and they might not be), then I would think that: - Anybody who isn't a mentor today might have a hard time becoming one.
- The universe of mentors will only get smaller over time (due to negative karma earned within here) - not bigger.
So in the spirit of the Ask Our Mentors forum, I guess my question is this: do I have a reason to be concerned?
Edited: The decision to move this original post from the Ask Our Mentors forum to the General Discussion forum rendered references like "this forum" confusing, so I clarified them.
|
|
Administrator |
This Administrator provided this Answer to the Question |
James R. Davis
Administrator
17375 Posts
[Mentor]
Houston, TX
USA
Honda
GoldWing 1500
|
Posted - 01/27/2009 : 1:07 PM
|
As you can see, this is an Associated Topic. It exists as a response to the concerns raised about Mentors being a 'limited' and potentially non-growing set of users, as a natural add-on feature to the Q&A feature, and as a way to allow members to avoid hijacking topics by being able to easily create a new, but associated, topic in which to launch into tangential ideas.
The 'HELP' feature (main menu) provides a brief discussion of the feature and I will provide a detailed description later as well.
Does this new feature actually address those objectives properly/adequately, or are there further enhancements that you might like to see here? |
 |
|
|
Question [To Administrators] |
|
|
|